At a summit at the Department of Justice today, FBI Director Christopher Wray shared cases where the support of technology companies helped law enforcement rapidly identify and save children being sexually abused. Wray asked technology companies for the renewed and ongoing support of the industry in investigations into child pornography, terrorism, and other crimes.
Many technology firms, including Facebook, have or plan to implement user-controlled end-to-end encryptions that will thwart the ability of law enforcement, with a court-ordered warrant, to find and prosecute people who document and share evidence of their crimes with others online. This will also end the ability of technology companies to monitor and then alert authorities to illegal, criminal, and violent content shared through their sites, according to the FBI.
“We all want safe, secure, private data, but we also want safe and secure communities. And we can have both.”
— FBI Director Christopher Wray
When it comes to child pornography, this is not a matter of a few images, according to the FBI. There is an ocean of horrific videos and photos being shared and commodified online. Technology companies reported 45 million of these images in 2018, according to a recent media analysis. The National Center for Missing & Exploited Children alone receives 18 million referrals a year.
Each image documents an act of violence against a child—some of them younger than 2 years old. Take a moment to consider what that number of images means for the children in your community, the child in your home.
“If we don’t take action and do something soon to address the lawful access problem, it will be too late, and we’ll lose the ability to find those kids who need to be rescued. We’re going to lose the ability to find the bad guys who need to be arrested and stopped. And we’re going to lose the ability to keep the most vulnerable people we serve safe from harm. We just cannot let that happen.”
— FBI Director Christopher Wray
Wray stressed that the goal of what must be an ongoing, joint conversation is not to demonize the technology companies who provide a valuable service and owe their users the assurance of privacy and security.
“We all want safe, secure, private data, but we also want safe and secure communities,” said Wray. “And we can have both. I really do believe that.”
Steven Grocki, chief of the Department of Justice’s Child Exploitation and Obscenity Section, detailed how child predators use these online sites not only to share images and tips to avoid detection, but to make the most deviant, violent behavior seem normal.
“We demand safety for our children in the physical world,” said Grocki as he showed an image of playground with rubberized safety mats. We don’t, however, bring the same standard to the digital world.
The FBI joins the law enforcement community in asking technology companies to envision a path to progress that encompasses the safety and well-being of children and communities.
“We’ve put some of the brightest minds in the country on the issue,” said Wray. “We’ve learned that it can, responsibly, be done.”
FBI Director Christopher Wray said Facebook is at risk of becoming a "dream come true" for child pornographers if it follows through with a plan to encrypt all of its users' messages https://t.co/KhtxHLAD6f
— CNN (@CNN) October 4, 2019
Discussing the dangers of end-to-end encryption with close allies AG Barr and @PeterDutton_MP at the US @TheJusticeDept today. We can not let tech firms design platforms that give serious criminals & terrorists the advantage. pic.twitter.com/rut9TePJ9M
— Priti Patel MP (@patel4witham) October 4, 2019
I am not opposed to end-to-end encryption. I am a strong believer in privacy. However, we need to create a solution that will safeguard the victims/survivors of child sexual abuse who's images are shared everyday online. This is why: pic.twitter.com/mGjcFHfmrO
— John Walsh (@john_walsh) October 4, 2019
We will stand with survivors who are opposed to the implementation of end-to-end encryption without an exception for detecting child sexual abuse imagery. Many survivors fear that this would remove their only hope for the removal of the images of their abuse from online. pic.twitter.com/3qNaHkh40X
— NCMEC (@MissingKids) October 3, 2019
^^ MOBILE? USE VOICE MIC ^^
facebook …
Please ‘LIKE’ the ‘Arlington Cardinal Page. See all of The Cardinal Facebook fan pages at Arlingtoncardinal.com/about/facebook …
Help fund The Cardinal Arlingtoncardinal.com/sponsor
20240105-1435future
THANKS FOR READING CARDINAL NEWS
Here we go again: US govt tells Facebook to kill end-to-end encryption for the sake of the children https://t.co/tYYXI6ISG2
— The Register (@TheRegister) October 4, 2019
Today we joined dozens of other civil society organizations to encourage Facebook and other tech companies to resist law enforcement calls to create backdoors or exceptional access to the content of users’ messages. https://t.co/DmDOFHGpLN
— EFF (@EFF) October 4, 2019
The broken record: Why Barr’s call against end-to-end encryption is nuts https://t.co/BVIuHFfVww by @thepacketrat
— Ars Technica (@arstechnica) October 4, 2019
Implementing end to end encryption is literally one of the only good things @facebook is doing. But #WilliamBarr would prefer to spy on your digital communications. Don't let him. https://t.co/fwtx0kcyXf
— Fight for the Future (@fightfortheftr) October 4, 2019