Haley Reinhart Survives, So-So Review of ‘Call Me’ and Paul McDonald Out

... #ad▼

Haley Reinhart, Wheeling
Haley Reinhart in top form back in March before voting for American Idol Season 10 (2011) semifinals.

April 14, 2011 Update

Haley Reinhart has survived as on of American Idol’s seven remaining contestants as Paul McDonald who was eliminated. Reinhart was among the bottom three vote recipients.

“Listen, honest, I didn’t love the beginning of it. At the end, you started getting into the song.”
— Randy Jackson

“The chorus was beautiful.”
— Steven Tyler

“… it wasn’t the best. After two killer performances like you just gave, baby, you’ve got to just keep taking it higher and higher.”
— Jennifer Lopez

April 7, 2011 Update
The news of the night was the upset drop of ‘American Idol front-runner Pia Toscano. But local news is Haley Reinhart is still showing strong.